In
previous lectures in EDUC 4P19 we have been discussing and analyzing curriculum
documents. The Know, Do, Be, framework is used as a guide when investigating
curriculum documents. The ‘Know’ encompasses all that students are expected to
learn while in school, from learning the names of the provinces to different
math equations. The ‘Do’ encompasses all the life skills that students are to
learn while in school, such as problem solving, and interpersonal skills.
Lastly, the ‘Be’ encompasses the values and behavioral attitudes that students
are supposed to gain while enrolled in school. While researching through the
Ontario and Manitoba curriculums for the front matter assignment, it was difficult to determine what values
these curriculums were trying to emphasize. If values are a major aspect of a
curriculum, why are they not more evident and observable in the documents? Why
are values not given the same precedent as learning expectations or life skills?
In the text, Interweaving Curriculum and
Classroom Assessment, it is discussed
how values and behavioral attitudes are to be interwoven within each subject
taught (Drake, Reid, & Kolohon 2014). In my own educational experience, I
have found that teachers all too often turn a blind eye to the importance of teaching
values within lessons, and only focus on teaching academic content.
I can think of a clear example in my last year of high school, when I had a teacher that neglected to teach values and solely focused on academic content. Each day in this class was very similar. My friends and I would walk into class, we would take our seats, and immediately the teacher would begin their lecture. There was very little interaction between the teacher and the students. From the beginning of class, to the bell, we would listen as the teacher lectured on and on. If the teacher has very little personal interaction with the students how can they teach values?
In a New York Times article titled, Curriculum or Not, Teachers Teach Values, the heart of the article speaks to the importance of student - teacher interaction in order to teach values. What I found interesting in this article is that they discuss how it is the small interactions between student and teacher where values are taught. For myself, I sometimes have the misconception that when I teach values in my classroom it will be by telling life stories, or through some influential speech. If you don't understand what I mean by an influential speech, this scene is a good depiction of how I think values could to be taught in school.
How awesome would it be to give a speech like this once in a while in our classrooms?
Retrieved from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiqdA1B3_Nc
However, according to this article, values can be taught in ways as simple as checking
to see if students did their homework. Simple measures such as this can help to
teach students the value of responsibility. Another simple gesture, such as
asking students how their days are going, can express the value of care. In the
article, one teacher was quoted as saying, “good teachers teach values
everyday.” As prospective teachers, we need to go further than planning lessons
that include learning expectations. We need to take the time to plan our
lessons, so that they include learning expectations, life skills, as well as
values. We need to teach the complete package.
"Good teachers teach values everyday."
It is a challenge to figure out how
to teach values in a class, but it is a whole other challenge to determine what
values to teach. As a teacher it is important to determine what values are
appropriate to teach, and what values are inappropriate to bring into the
classroom. In an article, What Values Should be Taught, it is mentioned that teachers should not teach students
what religion to follow, or what political party to stand by. With that being
said, I do think that it is acceptable for a teacher to express that they value
their faith. By doing this it can teach students to learn to value things in
their own life. If a student notices that a teacher really values their faith, this student might want their classmates to see what they really value in
life. The article also states that we should teach the values of society. Once
again we run into a further problem, as the values of society are not always
the values of everyone. This is evident in the news, as it has been well
documented that many people do not approve of the new sex-ed curriculum in
Ontario, because it goes against their values. As prospective teachers, how will
we deal with these challenges in our future classrooms?
Although the challenge of teaching
values in a classroom may seem difficult, and controversial, it certainly does
not have to be. There are many values in the world that people of all different
backgrounds can agree upon. Some of these foundational values may be love,
compassion, and respect. At first it may seem like an overwhelming challenge to
incorporate these values into a classroom, but as mentioned previously,
teaching values in a classroom can be very simple. Respect can be taught through
conflict resolution. If two students cannot get along, a great opportunity is
presented to teach these students about respect for one another.
In conclusion, as prospective
teachers we need to be able to teach the know, do and the BE. We cannot just
teach the know and do. Teaching values is just as important as teaching
learning expectations or life skills.
References
Drake, S.M., Reid, J.L., Kolohon, W. (2014). Interweaving curriculum and classroom assessment: Engaging the 21st- century learner. Canada: Oxford University Press.
Seefeldt, C. (2010). What values should be taught: Retrieved from http://www.education.com/reference/article/what-values-should-be-taught/
Mclarin, K. (1995). Curriculum or not, Teachers teach values. Retrieved from:http://www.nytimes.com/1995/02/01/nyregion/curriculum-or-not-teachers-teach-values.html?pagewanted=all
References
Drake, S.M., Reid, J.L., Kolohon, W. (2014). Interweaving curriculum and classroom assessment: Engaging the 21st- century learner. Canada: Oxford University Press.
Seefeldt, C. (2010). What values should be taught: Retrieved from http://www.education.com/reference/article/what-values-should-be-taught/
Mclarin, K. (1995). Curriculum or not, Teachers teach values. Retrieved from:http://www.nytimes.com/1995/02/01/nyregion/curriculum-or-not-teachers-teach-values.html?pagewanted=all
Hi Jesse,
ReplyDeleteI'd like to start off by saying that I really enjoyed your topic this week. You were able to effectively relate it to course content by explaining the Know, Do and Be system to really push your point. I especially enjoyed you introduction paragraph because you were able to provoke questioning to your readers.This allowed me to feel more engaged with the point you were trying to make.
I'd also like to comment on the video you chose. Wow, what a great speech. This was a perfect example of how a teacher can easily teach values in a way that isn't TELLING them what to believe in or value but instead he uses history to show the IMPORTANCE of valuing something at all. He made them feel something and that's what we need to do for our students.
I also enjoyed how you touched upon the effectiveness of the simple ways to interact with your students. You're right, although these ways are "simple", they can easily make an impact on students skills and values within and outside of the classroom.
Overall, I found this post very effective. You related it to the course, the news and yourself. You showed a great understanding of what it really means to teach values in a classroom. I encourage you to continue this great work. I now will remember to not just build lesson plans based on learning expectations but to build them with the inclusion of life skills and values.
Great Job and I look forward to your next post. :)
Hi Jesse,
ReplyDeleteGreat insights into the need to teach values in our classrooms today! This is a topic I debated on writing about in my own blog so I found it extra interesting to hear your point of view. Firstly, I have to say that I really enjoyed how you connected with the idea. You made it seem like something that is easily implemented in the classroom, which it really can be for dedicated educators.
Further you mentioned how important it is for educators to teach the importance of values. I really enjoyed how you did NOT say to teach the students your own values, but rather by teaching the students your values, student shave the chance to understand how important developing values is.
I also have to mention how much I love your video. Being one of my favourite movies of all time, I got excited as soon as I saw this was in your blog. I also thought it pertained to your topic really well. I don't want to ruin the video for anyone else, however the idea that teachers can influence their students to seek the importance of values was clearly present.
I also enjoyed how well you connected your idea of teaching values to the course material. You did a great job at connecting to the KDB idea we cover so in depth in class.
One area which could be further developed is a connection to how you would see yourself developing values in your classroom. So, Jesse, I'll leave you with this question: when you get into the profession, how will you choose to implement the teaching of values in your own room?
Great job! Keep up the good work in connecting to lecture content and developing your own ideas. Can't wait to read your next post!
Jesse, your second blog is well discussed that interconnects an academic analysis as well as a personal stance. I like how you began your blog with connecting and reflecting back on the education course you are taking now EDUC 4P19, as well as the Front Matter assignment. Your inclusion of these further enhances your knowledge and content of your subject matter. You emphasize the notion of the Know, Do, and Be that builds the framework of what students should know, what students should be able to do and what students should strive to be. Through this framework, the values are embedded in which they are taught by teachers, and it is the job of the teachers to teach the values to their students as they are the facilitators of their learning. The paragraphs are organized in a cohesive manner, transitioning well into the next paragraphs of information. Personal insights of a past high school experience exemplifies how teaching values are essential in the educational domain. And without such, students will not foster into respectful and kind individual beings. For example, you mentioned the example of your teacher who did not quite make class so interesting as there was no interaction between the teacher and student, thus an uncommunicative relation was formed that did not meet your educational needs. Your use of extended sources allowed your blog to be richer such as ‘What Values Should Be Taught’ and ‘Curriculum or Not, Teachers Teach Values’ analyzes that values are important to teach by the teacher to their students. Some constructive criticism I would like to suggest is that when you discuss the articles, you outline their main ideas but you could have provided some examples to enrich these understandings such as some interactions between the teacher and student. Discuss ‘what’ and ‘how’ these small interactions teach values for both teacher and student. But, overall good work on this blog and I enjoyed it.
ReplyDelete